What’s the Meaning of Life for Confucianism?

Confucianism seeks meaning through social harmony and ethical behavior but faces criticism for limiting personal autonomy and gender roles.

Nov 28, 2024By Viktoriya Sus, MA Philosophy

what is meaning life confucianism

 

The centuries-old Chinese philosophy of Confucianism tackles life’s big queries by offering guidelines and advice. One such question is: what does life mean? Philosophers have long tried to answer this, exploring how to find purpose and happiness in being alive. Confucius believed it was more useful to focus on how we live rather than why or where we are here at all. He stressed the importance of good actions plus social harmony as key ways forward. So, what does Confucianism tell us about the meaning of life?

 

Origins of the Study of the Meaning of Life in Philosophy

richard wilson tilovi painting
Tivoli; Temple of the Sibyl and the Campagna, Richard Wilson, 1765-70. Source: TATE

 

The philosophical issue of the meaning of life—or “What is the purpose of existence?”—affects everybody. Typically, this includes evaluating a person’s entire life, how they interact with reality, and what aims they set themselves beyond just existing.

 

Throughout history, various major philosophers, such as Confucius, Socrates, Plato, Descartes, and Spinoza, had clear notions about what kind of lives were “best” (and therefore most meaningful). Usually, they linked up the idea of meaning with that of good, but each in his own way, depending on what exactly was being taught by these schools.

 

For example, Aristotle said that happiness is the meaning and purpose of life, the only goal of human existence. He argued that each of us can achieve this state. To do this, you don’t need to be a consumer. Work and create something without getting hung up on material goods—just do good and love.

Get the latest articles delivered to your inbox

Sign up to our Free Weekly Newsletter

 

Aristotle was sure that for a happy life, a person needed friendship. Without friends and communication with others like oneself, a person’s life will be incomplete and meaningless.

 

On the contrary, Sartre was a proponent of atheistic existentialism. The philosopher was sure that all answers to the meaning of life were an illusion. Each person, in his opinion, lives within the framework of their own beliefs and thoughts, which do not in any way affect the existing reality.

 

Jean-Paul Sartre was convinced that our reality would exist without us. It does not depend in any way on our opinions or views. A person is doomed to experience the events throughout his life and attempts to rationally explain them.

 

Lao Tzu was sure that people needed to give up the pursuit of comfort and material wealth, forget about self-interest, and become themselves. The main guideline for every person should be spiritual growth and purity of thoughts. Only in this case will life acquire meaning, harmony, and value.

 

What Is Confucianism?

zhang zeduan along the river handscroll
Along the River during Qingming Festival, Zhang Zeduan, 11th-12th century. Source: Smart History

 

Confucianism, an ancient Chinese philosophy founded by the thinker Confucius in the 5th century BCE, offers lessons on ethics, morality, and social and political obligations.

 

Its most important aspect is the ideal of harmony—especially within families but more generally across society. Other key values promoted include righteousness (yi), wisdom (zhi), trustworthiness (xin), propriety (li), and kindness (ren). Advocates believe that together, they can cultivate integrity in society—making it almost unnecessary to have laws to maintain order.

 

One idea central to Confucianism is that people must work to improve themselves through learning. Confucius thought everyone could become virtuous if they tried hard enough.

 

Additionally, Confucianism emphasizes the importance of filial piety—a deep respect for your parents and ancestors—and respect for authority figures. It promotes strong family values and hierarchical relationships within society, focusing on our social roles and responsibilities.

 

Another core part of Confucian thinking is that harmony results from using etiquette and ritual correctly: they show us how to keep order in society by following the rules for behavior.

 

Confucius also thought leaders should be good people—not just powerful ones. He argued that ethical leadership could help make societies better places. Such leaders would act fairly towards everyone while also promoting justice (fairness) and respect between individuals themselves.

 

Confucian Approach to Life’s Meaning

huang gongwang fuchun mountains painting
Dwelling in the Fuchun Mountains, Huang Gongwang, 1348-50. Source: Wikimedia Commons

 

Thanks to its pragmatic outlook, Confucianism offers a unique perspective on the question of life’s meaning. According to Confucius, who founded this philosophical tradition in China over two millennia ago, we can find purpose by fulfilling our social roles and responsibilities while cultivating virtuous character.

 

At the heart of Confucian philosophy is a concept called ren, often translated as “benevolence.” In practice, this means developing compassion and empathy for others and treating them with kindness and respect. By acting this way consistently—by being benevolent—we contribute to a harmonious society where people can lead meaningful lives.

 

For Confucius, real fulfillment comes from behaving ethically in ways that benefit everyone around us. He stressed that it’s important to embrace yi—”rightness”—so we make choices based on what we genuinely believe is right rather than what might be most convenient at any given moment.

 

Aligning our actions with moral values helps give us a sense of purpose. When we do good things, we feel like we’re making society better.

 

Moreover, self-cultivation is vital in Confucianism. Individuals are encouraged to continue learning and growing personally throughout their lives. Confucius believed education was key to uncovering profound truths about existence and understanding our place within society.

 

Learning isn’t just about acquiring knowledge. It also helps us develop virtuous characteristics that make life worthwhile.

 

Also fundamental to Confucian thought regarding the meaning of life is filial piety—unquestioning respect for parents and ancestors. By honoring those who came before us, we ensure that their values endure across generations while fostering strong relationships with others.

 

When we cherish our roots in this way, we keep an awareness of connectedness alive inside ourselves, contributing to personal fulfillment.

 

Individual Purpose vs. Collective Harmony

edward hicks peacable kingdom painting
Peaceable Kingdom, Edward Hicks, c. 1830-32. Source: The MET

 

The concept of individual purpose in Confucianism combines both individualistic and collectivist ideas. In this philosophy, everyone has a role they’re meant to play in life—but achieving it requires following certain rules within society.

 

Individual purposes can include things like personal growth or wanting something specific out of life. However, Confucian teachings say those desires should always consider what your family and community expect from you, too.

 

A person who does that—who considers others along with themselves—is called “good” by Confucius. According to him, someone who acts kindly toward others will also end up being happier.

 

For people who follow these ideas, simply thinking about what we want for ourselves isn’t enough: It’s about finding ways to pursue goals that benefit everybody!

 

Another aspect of finding your purpose in life is fulfilling what society expects from you. Think about being a good parent or child, even if it’s difficult sometimes. Or working hard at your job because it helps society function.

 

If people do these things well, everyone benefits—and they feel happier, too. Research shows that contributing to something bigger than yourself makes us happy!

 

Confucius thought this was important, too: he said our family and social duties are connected. To find meaning in life, he believed we need strong family bonds because looking after relatives properly matters for individuals’ happiness and society’s overall well-being.

 

In other words, according to Confucianism, genuinely fulfilling lives involve developing virtues such as loyalty or respect towards others rather than going it alone all the time.

 

Criticisms and Challenges of Confucian Views

georges seurat sunday on la grande painting
A Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte, Georges Seurat, 1884-86. Source: Wikimedia Commons

 

Although Confucianism offers valuable insights into the meaning of life, it is not without its critics. One critique emphasizes social harmony and collective well-being over individual wants and desires.

 

Critics argue that this focus could mean that Confucian values do not place enough importance on personal freedom and autonomy, potentially limiting our chances of finding meaning for ourselves.

 

Another issue with Confucianism today might be its reliance on hierarchical relationships: always thinking about who’s above and below you. Critics say this way of thinking can stop people from asking questions or changing things when they need to—like if something isn’t fair or right!

 

Some people don’t fit into Confucian ideas about what families should look like anymore because society has recently changed. But it might still be worthwhile to find purpose through other kinds of groups instead (like friends).

 

In addition, people argue that Confucianism might prioritize conformity more than personal expression or originality. The importance of following particular rules and rituals might stop new ideas or different ways of finding purpose from developing.

 

There are also problems with Confucianism’s usual approach to men and women. If it always says men should do one thing and women should do another, this can make unfair differences between them even bigger. Critics say this stops women from making choices for themselves about what gives their lives meaning.

 

But we need to know that there have been many different interpretations of Confucianism over time—it hasn’t meant just one thing in hundreds of years! Some modern scholars are looking again at issues like these: they want to think about how things might be now when saying what’s important in life.

 

So, What’s the Problem With the Confucian Interpretation of the Meaning of Life?

paul gauguin where do we come painting
Where Do We Come From? What Are We? Where Are We Going?, Paul Gauguin, 1897-98. Source: Museum of Fine Arts

 

The Confucian view of life’s meaning is not easily classified as all good or all bad. It does have strengths worth considering—especially its focus on behaving ethically, creating social harmony, and promoting shared well-being.

 

Confucianism provides people with ways of finding purpose by being responsible, fulfilling their societal roles, and building strong family bonds. However, one major issue with this viewpoint could be that it overlooks personal values and desires. How individuals feel about what gives life significance might not always be considered.

 

Paying attention to obligations towards others and fitting in with established norms might mean less emphasis gets placed (perhaps inadvertently) on things like autonomy or self-expression. It can lead some to feel stifled or unfulfilled if what matters most to them personally doesn’t line up exactly with Confucian ideas.

 

So, while communal welfare matters, surely there must also be room for people to figure out individually what makes their lives meaningful. Maybe that involves different values altogether—something we need more discussion around if everyone will find ways to live meaningfully together.



Author Image

By Viktoriya SusMA PhilosophyViktoriya is a writer from L’viv, Ukraine. She has knowledge about the main thinkers. In her free time, she loves to read books on philosophy and analyze whether ancient philosophical thought is relevant today. Besides writing, she loves traveling, learning new languages, and visiting museums.